Home About Find a Consultant How to Join Documents Links ECANSW Forum Positions Vacant


Available Topics
2009 ECA Conference 2010 ECA Conference Accreditation of Ecological Consultants Ants: The Natural Enemy of the Nest Box
Australia 2020 Summit Biobanking 2008: Its coming, ready or not... Biobanking assessor accreditation Biocertification
Blacks eating browns Blindsiding "Community Charity Magazine Advertising" Buffers Bush Tucker
Changes in Abundance of Migratory Shorebirds in Eastern Australia Coastal ecology Consultancy Fee Proposals Correct Spelling of Common Names of Bird Species
Damselfy on the Cover of Vol 21 Dead tree - stag or snag? Disturbances to Urban Waterbirds ECA Conference
ECA Conference 2008 ECA Workshops 2008 Elliott Trapping Ethical dilemma
Flora of the Sydney Region Flying-foxes and nectar in northern NSW GeneralNew strategic process for development to be tested in Kimberley Glossy Black Cockatoo Food Trees
How to Erect Nest Boxes and Recycled Hollow-Limbs Infrared Spotlights/Night Vision Optics Insurance Cover Introduction of native speices
Koalas Legal Responsibilities of Consultants Little Red Flying-foxes(?) At Penrith Marketing Scams
Marking Habitat Trees Miscellaneous Observations Mosquito Control NPWS Wildlife Atlas, Is it useful?
Nyctophilus timoriensis Planted threatened plants need 7 part test Pollution Law Prepaid Wireless Broadband
Published Field Guides RFEF on Coastal Floodplains: Where the bloody hell is it? Recommended Suppliers of Ecological Equipment Recycling office products
Reintroduction of native species Remote Sensor Digital Cameras Removing Tapes from Hair-tubes SEPP44
Safety Clothing vs Bird Survey Efficacy Scorpions Seasonal Trapability of Southern Brown Bandicoots Snake Tongs: Not ethical
Some comments on the limitations of Insurance Policies ECA members should b Sulphur-feathered Cockatoo Tadpole Traps Taxonomic Changes to Australian Birds
Terminology Threatened Fish Usage of Arboreal Termite Nests and Epiphytic Ferns by Fauna Vegetation Management Plans
Video Cams Walkie Talkies What a Graduate Should Know What is an EEC?
What! A Spotted-tailed Quoll in an A Elliot When does an introduced animal become considered a When does an introduced animal become considered a "native" species. non-natural habitat usage
view current topics


There are 6 messages under the topic 'Correct Spelling of Common Names of Bird Species'
Posted by : Edward Cannella 19/04/10 1:31 am

Stephen, I hope not to disappoint you but I have had two reports returned with notations to comply with the Style Guide (one report was edited by DEWHA and the other by WA DEC). Their main concern was the use of capital letters for species common names. To be honest we really should not be discussing this issue at all. As you have rightly pointed out, the reports are "international" publications. As such they need to be of the standards that apply to the preparation of journal articles.


Posted by : Stephen Ambrose 09/04/10 11:27 am

Edward has quite rightly pointed out the inconsistency of accepted styles for common names. English names of birds in the international literature are capitalised (as per Rule No. 1 of International Ornithologists Committee, IOC), whereas those of other animal groups generally aren't unless they are proper names. The Australian Style Guide seems to overlook the IOC rule and does not recommend capiltalisation of common names of any (animal and plant)species unless they are proper names.

My feeling is that any written reports should be regarded as international literature (even site-specific consultants' reports) because they usually end up, or have the potential of appearing, on the internet. Therefore, I follow the prescribed styles of international bodies such as the IOC. But I'm sure that a consent or compliance authority, or client, is not going to mind what style you choose!


Posted by : Edward Cannella 07/04/10 9:47 am

According to the Australian Style Guide common names do not need to be capitalised unless they include a proper name (i.e., Lewin's honeyeater is correct, as is red-tailed black-cockatoo). There are many other quirks in the style guide that reflect a dumbing down of the use of the english language and grammar in writing. Pretty soon they will be removing punctuation although, given some of the reports I have read, it seems to have started already. By the way, I am ignoring much of the style guide.


Posted by : Elizabeth Ashby 18/02/10 12:46 am

Although clumsy, sometimes wrong and inconsistent, I have tried to always use the common name of threatened species as they are listed, as this is the legal entity.

And don't start me on common names for plants! It seems that the Atlas is just making them up to dumb it down. Common names are rubbish in botanical circles. I vote we try and get rid of them.


Posted by : Stephen Ambrose 29/01/10 3:34 pm

There's a great discussion on Wikipedia about the variety of conventions used for vernacular names of other fauna groups and a call for international standardisation. Check it out:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia_talk: Naming_conventions_(fauna)

 

 


Posted by : Stephen Ambrose 29/01/10 2:19 pm

Many consultants apear to be confused about how to spell correctly the common names of bird species. For instance, I have seen the correctly spelled Bar-tailed Godwit variously written as Bar-Tailed Godwit, bar-tailed godwit, Bar Tailed Godwit, Bar tailed Godwit, bar tailed godwit, Bartailed Godwit, bartailed godwit and even BarTailed Godwit.

The spelling rules used by the International Ornithological Congress (IOC) in its list of bird species of the world are listed below:

Spelling Rules

1. Official Englsih names of birds must be capitalized (e.g. Yellow-throated Scrubwren);

2. Patronyms must be used in the possessive case (e.g. Smith's, Ross's)

3. Names must not include diacritical marks.

4. Geographical words in a name may be in noun or adjective form but must be consistent for that location (e.g. Australia Shelduck should not be a substitute for Australian Shelduck).

5. Use of hyphens in compound group names to indicate relationships between species should be minimised. (This rule is sometimes ignored in naming Australian birds, e.g. the Black-Cockatoos).

6. Hyphens should be used in compound names only to connect two names that are birds or bird families (e.g. Cuckoo-shrike) or when the named would otherwise be difficult to read (e.g. White-eye)




You must register or login to post messages


 
Ecological Consultants Association of NSW Inc.