Home About Find a Consultant How to Join Documents Links ECANSW Forum Positions Vacant


Available Topics
2009 ECA Conference 2010 ECA Conference Accreditation of Ecological Consultants Ants: The Natural Enemy of the Nest Box
Australia 2020 Summit Biobanking 2008: Its coming, ready or not... Biobanking assessor accreditation Biocertification
Blacks eating browns Blindsiding "Community Charity Magazine Advertising" Buffers Bush Tucker
Changes in Abundance of Migratory Shorebirds in Eastern Australia Coastal ecology Consultancy Fee Proposals Correct Spelling of Common Names of Bird Species
Damselfy on the Cover of Vol 21 Dead tree - stag or snag? Disturbances to Urban Waterbirds ECA Conference
ECA Conference 2008 ECA Workshops 2008 Elliott Trapping Ethical dilemma
Flora of the Sydney Region Flying-foxes and nectar in northern NSW GeneralNew strategic process for development to be tested in Kimberley Glossy Black Cockatoo Food Trees
How to Erect Nest Boxes and Recycled Hollow-Limbs Infrared Spotlights/Night Vision Optics Insurance Cover Introduction of native speices
Koalas Legal Responsibilities of Consultants Little Red Flying-foxes(?) At Penrith Marketing Scams
Marking Habitat Trees Miscellaneous Observations Mosquito Control NPWS Wildlife Atlas, Is it useful?
Nyctophilus timoriensis Planted threatened plants need 7 part test Pollution Law Prepaid Wireless Broadband
Published Field Guides RFEF on Coastal Floodplains: Where the bloody hell is it? Recommended Suppliers of Ecological Equipment Recycling office products
Reintroduction of native species Remote Sensor Digital Cameras Removing Tapes from Hair-tubes SEPP44
Safety Clothing vs Bird Survey Efficacy Scorpions Seasonal Trapability of Southern Brown Bandicoots Snake Tongs: Not ethical
Some comments on the limitations of Insurance Policies ECA members should b Sulphur-feathered Cockatoo Tadpole Traps Taxonomic Changes to Australian Birds
Terminology Threatened Fish Usage of Arboreal Termite Nests and Epiphytic Ferns by Fauna Vegetation Management Plans
Video Cams Walkie Talkies What a Graduate Should Know What is an EEC?
What! A Spotted-tailed Quoll in an A Elliot When does an introduced animal become considered a When does an introduced animal become considered a "native" species. non-natural habitat usage
view current topics


There are 2 messages under the topic 'Ethical dilemma'
Posted by : Stephen Ambrose 24/08/07 9:46 am

I suspect that you have grounds for suing the company that listed you as a sub-consultant in the tendering process, if you could prove legally that it used your name to (in part) win the contract. Proving this in a court of law may be difficult, though.

If I was in your situation, I would be sending a strong letter to the offending consultant company, via your lawyer, threatening legal action if such an incident occurred again.

 


Posted by : Deryk Engel 20/08/07 10:38 am

I was approached last year by a company to undertake a specialist study. The primary client specified three firms that had to be approached/used, it up to the various tenderers to choose which one they approached. Two firms bidding on the project approached me and I submitted the same price. I heard nothing for several months and in the end rang both firms to see if they were successful. One wasn’t, one was. When I contacted the successful firm they told me the project had been completed and they had engaged another firm to undertake the required specialist study. What bothers me about all this is, to win their tender, they used my name and firm as required by the brief. Having me as part of their team (presumably) went part way towards them winning the project. So what should I do? Rhetorical question I know but where do you stand when your name has been used to win a tender, but your not part of the project team? Its not the money or project I'm worried about, but the fact that a) I wasted time putting a submission together and b) was one of the specified firms that the proponent specified had to be used. Is this sour grapes on my part or is there an obligation for clients to use the firms they approach, particularly as they are directed by the Proponent and have won the project using that sub-consultants name?




You must register or login to post messages


 
Ecological Consultants Association of NSW Inc.